| For this oral history paper I was very excited to find someone with a
quite interesting and
culturally diverse family background that I think would
contribute a lot to the topic of prejudice and stereotype. This paper will
discuss the views of stereotype and prejudice of my interviewee and also how the
two factors have affected her life. Brown (1995) defines prejudice as a negative
attitude, emotion, or behavior towards members of a group as a result of their
membership of that group. This negative attitude, emotion, or behavior that we
project toward members of a particular group is influenced by the attitudes of
others around us and the norms of our ingroup. In this paper I would try to use
the interviewee’s stories which in many instances are filled with treatments of
prejudices and stereotypes coming from herself and others.
The person I
interview is FDG, a 23 year-old female college student with a Motion
Picture/Movie Production at the Academy of Art in San Francisco. FDG was born
and raised in Jakarta, Indonesia. Her father is Indonesian and her mother is
from Turkmenistan (formerly part of the Soviet Union). Her father comes from a
very religious (Moslem) family in Sumatra and it was quite a horror to his
family when he decided to marry a foreign Jewish girl (her mother then converted
to Islam when FDG was 7 years old). FDG comes from a very comfortable economic
background, both her parents are chemical engineers. FDG said that she grew up
in a very sheltered environment where almost every she needed were provided for.
As a child of a mixed raced couple, FDG becomes a member of the minority
group in the country she was living in where most couples come from similar
economic, religious, and ethnic backgrounds. FDG now acknowledges that during
her childhood and adolescence she had encountered and experienced stereotyping
and prejudice.
Because Russian is her first language, in kindergarten she
was teased by her friends for not being able to speak Indonesian fluently and
looking different than the others. “I’ve always hated my blonde hair,” says FDG,
“one time a friend accused me of being an albino Indonesian… I guess he couldn’t
accept the fact that I had a Russian mother with blonde her too!” In the 4th
grade she got into a fight and punched a classmate after he yelled, “Go back to
where you belong… you Russian terrorist!” FDG remarks that looking back at her
experiences she is still surprised that even at an early stage of a child’s
life, her peers had already absorbed so many stereotypes and prejudice thought
of other people that are not necessarily true. FDG admits that it was a very sad
and confusing period of her life because she has always considered herself to be
100% Indonesian. Although she speaks Russian and looks more like a Caucasian
rather than an Asian girl, she has never visited the country nor does she know
anything about its culture. FDG tells that she made an unconscious decision to
separate herself from her mother’s heritage due to the mocking she hears from
her friends about her mother’s culture. It is also due to the lack of knowledge
and information that leads her to unwillingly buy into all the negative
comments. Moreover, FDG mentions that her mother has never made an effort to
introduce or familiarize FDG about her Russian ancestry. FDG was very confused
and literally did not know where she belonged. She had lived all of her life in
Indonesia and was only taught about the traditional Indonesian values only, not
Russian. The only culture (Indonesian) she knew about and considered to be a
part of turned out to reject her. And on the other hand people expect her to
belong to a foreign culture that she did not know anything about. Thus, FDG at
first presumed that she is a part of the ingroup whereas others perceived her as
an outgroup member. As a result, growing up FDG rarely had close native
Indonesian friends at school and instead she made friends with other mixed-race
children and children of expatriates in Indonesia.
In the interview FDG
talked a lot about the role that her parents have played in her life, especially
her mother, in helping her to adjust and cope to the environment that can be
harsh sometimes, especially while she was growing up. According to FDG since her
father was always away for his work most of the time, her mother has a greater
role in her life. Growing up, FDG always had her mother on her side to guide and
support her. By listening to FDG, it was obvious that her behavior, attitude and
views of life are greatly influenced by her mother’s thoughts and feelings.
FDG agrees with Bruner (1957) that social categorization or stereotyping is
an inescapable feature of human existence. Bruner suggested that by assigning
individuals based on their similarities and differences, we could deal with them
much more efficiently. FDG argues that at times social categorization or
stereotyping is helpful, in terms of making social decisions.
FDG parents
did not restrict her from choosing her friends nor did they teach her to be
prejudiced. However, there are a few exceptions, a set of rules, that she had to
obey when it comes to selecting a boyfriend. Ironically, the most important
thing that her parents instilled in her is the fact that she is forbidden to
date people outside of her race. Moreover, she can only go out with a Moslem boy
who is preferably did not come from a broken family (his parents are not
separated or divorced). By setting up such rules, FDG feels that her parents are
being some kind of hypocrites, especially for restricting her with so many rules
while she knows they have also broken by marrying a person with a different
religion and from a different race. With this FDG feels that her parents have
helped shape her to be a person with a negative attitude or prejudice towards
others from different religious, social or ethic background. Almost
instantaneously after making this comment, FDG comes into her parents defend by
saying that although sometimes her parents may seem to be too overpowering and
strict she believes that they only means well.
Funnily enough FDG tells me
that she has a special philosophy that some rules are created to be broken. She
claims to be a rebel and probably has tried to do what her parents forbid her
from doing. When I ask her if she has ever violated the dating rules set up by
her parents, FDG replies that she has but often she does it just to spite her
parents.
Throughout the interview I sense some hesitation from FDG in terms
of giving her views concerning prejudice. As the interview went on, FDG tells me
that as a result of the current ethnic disputes (between the native Indonesians
and Chinese Indonesians), stereotyping and prejudice are two very sensitive
issues in her country now. Also after going through such a horrible abuse of
prejudice in her childhood, the issue really hits close to home. FDG argues that
most native Indonesians think of themselves as better individuals than the
ethnic Chinese people, just because they were born as native Indonesian. FDG
concludes that the view of the ethnic Chinese to be greedy, not humble, steal
from the native Indonesian’s businesses, and oppressive. By making this comment
it can be presumed that FDG has also bought into the general stereotype that
Indonesians have regarding Chinese people. When asked why she thinks of them
that way, she cannot tell me the reasons why (Ingroup Bias). All she says, “that
is just the way they are and what Indonesian kids are told when they are
little.”
From all of the traumatic experience that FDG have had to endure,
she said that the act of putting people into groups because they share common
interests or value as well as prejudice have still somehow manage to enter her
mind. Even if she was discriminated against because of her mixed heritage, FDG
knows that she is not as unfortunate as being categorized in the Chinese group.
FDG knows what it feels like to be prejudiced against, without realizing it she
still cannot help from being a prejudiced person herself towards certain members
of one group (Chinese Indonesians). Like many of other native Indonesians, she
also has adopted some prejudiced views against Chinese Indonesians. When I ask
FDG if she realizes that she is treating this particular group with the same
stereotypes and prejudices that she was treated with while she was living in
Indonesia, she says yes. FDG said that she acknowledges it but later on comments
that she cannot help but be influenced by the perception of the majority.
Although FDG may always encounter prejudices and stereotypes in the future,
she now know that it is important to get to know a person based on their
intelligence and not by their ethnic backgrounds. Now that she is living in a
more “international” environment such as San Francisco, I think FDG is now able
to broaden her perception towards prejudices and stereotypes and hopefully she
will finally come to terms with her own diverse heritage and not have negative
perceptions regarding others that are different from herself.
|
|